I was having a discussion with a mate who plays WoW the other day about changes we would like to see in the game. I had a nice list going, so I thought I should post the ideas here and see what people think. Some of these have made the rounds before and some are new, to me at least.
New Druid Forms
Since I have a druid main, my first wish is some change to the druid forms. I have been the same ugly cat since I hit level 20, and the dire bear form is getting pretty old at this point too. I would love new elite textures and models for our forms, especially if there were several new ones to choose from. Additional models and textures only available to feral druids for cat and bear would be icing on the cake. I would love for all of these forms to have unique quest lines, but that might be asking too much since we already have a 70 class quest line for epic flying form. A different approach would be craftable, or vendor available, cosmetic armor for use on our current forms.
Gear Colors
I have always wanted some sort of color changing options for gear, be it dye or multiple selectable looks for a specific armor piece. I am tired of looking like a rainbow and getting an awesome piece of gear that makes it worse isn’t a huge let down. I have looked at other MMORPGs and been jealous of their gear dying options. The solution EQ2 has implemented, with a paper doll for looks and a separate one for stats, seems like a good middle option. I believe that Blizzard prefers to maintain control over the colors so that each item is easily recognizable compared to similar textured and modeled items, and so they can maintain the artistic look of the game. Making people with the best gear visually recognizable makes it more of an achievement to have that gear. There have been arguments that for pvp you need to be able to recognize gear to react correctly to different situations. I think none of these arguments really stand up. The models for the epic gear should be unique and then the colors don’t matter as much. The colors available can be limited to disallow too much artistic license, although, they already have pink shirts and tabards available now, so what more harm could be done?
Languages
The first time I realized that my Night Elf hunter could speak in Darnassian I was very excited. I thought, as you would, that eventually through a quest or a trainer I could learn other languages and possibly learn to speak to the other faction. I was sad to learn that this was not possible, and over my time in WoW this has always been something I hoped would be patched in. I think this is an opportunity for a new profession or secondary profession. The languages could require long quest lines, and would allow you to trade with any race whose language you know. I think this offers a lot of potential benefits and fun that are missing from the game.
Cross Faction Interaction
With the increase in cooperation between the Horde and the Alliance in the Burning Crusade, it is time for cross faction interaction and grouping. The language changes I suggested above could be the beginning of this integration. Eventually allowing cross faction access to cities and auction house, and linking all auctions. This would allow servers with low populations, or imbalanced Alliance to Horde ratios, to have better access to buy and sell. The integration should also allow cross faction instance groups. This would assist all levels in finding groups easier, and allow for more diversity in grouping. This would be a huge change, and would require a lot of work to sort out, but I think it would be worth it for playability reasons. There are lore repercussions and pvp issues, but I think it could be done. With the advent of Horde vs. Horde arena matches the pvp based arguments are void. World pvp is dead anyway, and if you really wanted to you could integrate the battleground teams also, with a little lore tweaking. This request has nothing to do with my two alliance 60 characters rotting away unplayed on the same server as my horde mains and guild, nothing at all, I swear.
I have some other requests as well, cross server instances, new low level zones, new classes, and new races, but I am out of time to write today. I may post about them another time. What do you think of the ones I have detailed or mentioned? Should Blizzard look to implement them? If not, why not?
Showing posts with label druid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label druid. Show all posts
Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Hybrid value: 3 roles, one class
My first commenter and good rogue mate, Lale, brought up a good question in the comments yesterday, which I think I will address.
“I would like to make a quick point up for debate = hybrids are good at many, masters of none. I have seen times where a druid tank has been a far better option than a warrior. Has the shift in the game changed? Can hybrids now be masters of particular roles? I smell a new post today...”
I made a point in the post to focus on classes, not talent specializations. This was because including talent trees into the discussion muddies the waters a bit more. With in hybrid classes the talent trees allow you to either focus on one role, or spread talent points around and gain a hybrid setup. The confusing part is that even in a so called pure class, like a priest, talent specialization allows players to play different roles or a hybrid mix.
That said, I think I can still answer to your question. When a hybrid class focuses on any specific role, they can be as effective as the focused pure class at that role, while bringing additional abilities outside that role. They may not have all the exact same abilities as the pure class, but the skills they do have should allow equal capability to fill the role. Before TBC talent trees, gear and the new 70 skills, the hybrid classes actually only had one role they could effectively spec into, healing. This has been resolved and now druids can be great healers, tanks, and melee or spell damage dealers. Paladins can be healers, tanks, and melee damage dealer.
If a hybrid class puts his talents in multiple trees then he becomes the jack of all trades player that you are talking about. In that case he is less effective at all roles then a focused primary or hybrid class, but can more effectively switch roles on the fly. This is the same as a pure class, like a priest, who can specialize into healing or damage dealing, or a mix of the two. I think that the hybrid classed have better synergy in the design of our talent trees post-TBC, which allows us to use a hybrid talent build more effectively then say a hybrid specialized warrior or priest. Druids, for instance, have a feral talent that translates strength into +heal, and restoration talents lower in the tree that effect rage generation and damage in feral forms.
With the number of talent points players now have at 70 they will generally specialize into one role mainly and then still have enough points to get a hybrid level specialization in another role. For instance my paladin is currently 41 points into holy, and 20 points into protection. This allows him more survivability then a full holy build, which is very helpful in pvp and surviving bad pulls in pve. He could also tank instances effectively, if he had the proper gear.
This brings up one final issue that all classes face, especially hybrid classes, the issue of gearing. If a class plays one role all the time, like most pure classes, then they only need one set of gear. They may want other bits for different uses like pvp, or resistance gear, but your gear is mainly one set. Hybrid classes, on the other hand, will need a fully different set for each role they want to play. If they attempt to use a hybrid set of gear, with a mix of stats for different roles, then they will be less effective at each of those roles then the pure class, even if they are fully specialized into that role at the time. It is the same as if a warrior attempted to use his tanking gear with an arms build to deal damage in an instance, it would not be nearly as effective as if he switched to gear with the proper stats for arms. A hybrid specialized player, hybrid or pure class, will be able to use role specific gear to buff his abilities in a certain role, or use a hybrid gear setup to improve his abilities across all roles by a smaller amount.
The biggest hassle of playing a hybrid class is getting the proper gear to effectively play the roles that people expect of you. On my druid, I have 4 sets of gear in Item Rack, I have a healing set, a bear set, a cat set, and a hybrid set. That is a lot of gear to carry around and more importantly to collect, even if there is some overlap. It makes it hard to have a good level of gear for all the roles you play in a group. I would always recommend gearing up for your main role first and then working through the other gear sets. In my guild I am known for snatching up anything that would add to my gear sets, be it caster, melee, or tank gear. They may complain at the time that they missed out on a shard, but when the gear is needed to save their bacon I have it available.
So in review, you have 4 requirements to play a hybrid class as a master of a particular role. First, pick the correct class that will allow you to play the role you want. Second, pick the proper talent specialization for the role. Third, gather the proper gear to play the role. Fourth, you must have imagination to use the class to its fullest potential. You do all that, and you can beat out pure classes in an otherwise equal situation. Remember you have skills they can never match, so make sure you take advantage of them when the situation allows. Don’t just stay in cat form dealing damage if the healer is out of mana, and the mage is getting hammered on. Switch to caster form, throw the healer an innervate, switch to bear form, and taunt the mob off the mage. You do that, and they will take you over that uber geared, damage meter whoring rogue every time!
“I would like to make a quick point up for debate = hybrids are good at many, masters of none. I have seen times where a druid tank has been a far better option than a warrior. Has the shift in the game changed? Can hybrids now be masters of particular roles? I smell a new post today...”
I made a point in the post to focus on classes, not talent specializations. This was because including talent trees into the discussion muddies the waters a bit more. With in hybrid classes the talent trees allow you to either focus on one role, or spread talent points around and gain a hybrid setup. The confusing part is that even in a so called pure class, like a priest, talent specialization allows players to play different roles or a hybrid mix.
That said, I think I can still answer to your question. When a hybrid class focuses on any specific role, they can be as effective as the focused pure class at that role, while bringing additional abilities outside that role. They may not have all the exact same abilities as the pure class, but the skills they do have should allow equal capability to fill the role. Before TBC talent trees, gear and the new 70 skills, the hybrid classes actually only had one role they could effectively spec into, healing. This has been resolved and now druids can be great healers, tanks, and melee or spell damage dealers. Paladins can be healers, tanks, and melee damage dealer.
If a hybrid class puts his talents in multiple trees then he becomes the jack of all trades player that you are talking about. In that case he is less effective at all roles then a focused primary or hybrid class, but can more effectively switch roles on the fly. This is the same as a pure class, like a priest, who can specialize into healing or damage dealing, or a mix of the two. I think that the hybrid classed have better synergy in the design of our talent trees post-TBC, which allows us to use a hybrid talent build more effectively then say a hybrid specialized warrior or priest. Druids, for instance, have a feral talent that translates strength into +heal, and restoration talents lower in the tree that effect rage generation and damage in feral forms.
With the number of talent points players now have at 70 they will generally specialize into one role mainly and then still have enough points to get a hybrid level specialization in another role. For instance my paladin is currently 41 points into holy, and 20 points into protection. This allows him more survivability then a full holy build, which is very helpful in pvp and surviving bad pulls in pve. He could also tank instances effectively, if he had the proper gear.
This brings up one final issue that all classes face, especially hybrid classes, the issue of gearing. If a class plays one role all the time, like most pure classes, then they only need one set of gear. They may want other bits for different uses like pvp, or resistance gear, but your gear is mainly one set. Hybrid classes, on the other hand, will need a fully different set for each role they want to play. If they attempt to use a hybrid set of gear, with a mix of stats for different roles, then they will be less effective at each of those roles then the pure class, even if they are fully specialized into that role at the time. It is the same as if a warrior attempted to use his tanking gear with an arms build to deal damage in an instance, it would not be nearly as effective as if he switched to gear with the proper stats for arms. A hybrid specialized player, hybrid or pure class, will be able to use role specific gear to buff his abilities in a certain role, or use a hybrid gear setup to improve his abilities across all roles by a smaller amount.
The biggest hassle of playing a hybrid class is getting the proper gear to effectively play the roles that people expect of you. On my druid, I have 4 sets of gear in Item Rack, I have a healing set, a bear set, a cat set, and a hybrid set. That is a lot of gear to carry around and more importantly to collect, even if there is some overlap. It makes it hard to have a good level of gear for all the roles you play in a group. I would always recommend gearing up for your main role first and then working through the other gear sets. In my guild I am known for snatching up anything that would add to my gear sets, be it caster, melee, or tank gear. They may complain at the time that they missed out on a shard, but when the gear is needed to save their bacon I have it available.
So in review, you have 4 requirements to play a hybrid class as a master of a particular role. First, pick the correct class that will allow you to play the role you want. Second, pick the proper talent specialization for the role. Third, gather the proper gear to play the role. Fourth, you must have imagination to use the class to its fullest potential. You do all that, and you can beat out pure classes in an otherwise equal situation. Remember you have skills they can never match, so make sure you take advantage of them when the situation allows. Don’t just stay in cat form dealing damage if the healer is out of mana, and the mage is getting hammered on. Switch to caster form, throw the healer an innervate, switch to bear form, and taunt the mob off the mage. You do that, and they will take you over that uber geared, damage meter whoring rogue every time!
Monday, October 29, 2007
Hybrid love, pure imagination
I love playing hybrid classes, but before going on about why, I suppose I should explain what I mean by hybrid. The dictionary defines a hybrid as something of mixed origin or composition. We are talking composition in this case, so what elements are we mixing in our composition, or class? The roles a class can fill in an instance would is its defining elements. There are 3 main roles, tanking, damage dealing, and healing. Crowd control, buffing and de-buffing tend to fall into one of the main roles already listed, and can be thought of as sub-roles. So we have the elements, or roles, that get combined to create our composition, or class. By the definition, we would assume that we need two or more of these roles to create a hybrid class.
This definition is close, and excludes classes like rogues and mages, which are clearly not hybrid. On the other hand, if you spend too long thinking about it you could claim that most classes in WoW are hybrid. All classes are a mix of damage dealing and some other role. A warrior can be damage dealer and a tank. A priest can be a damage dealer and a healer. This isn’t what I mean by a hybrid class, so how do I define it clearer so it excludes these classes? Well, I think we can safely assume that every class in wow has some flavor of damage dealing available to it through talent trees. So if we exclude this as one of the roles that can be combined to create a hybrid class, we can assume that any class without the ability to heal and tank is not a hybrid class.
This definition limits us to the druid and paladin classes, excluding even shamans which are traditionally thought of as hybrid. People think of shamans as hybrid because they heal and deal damage, but that is no different that a priest, which is most definitely not a hybrid class. I guess you could also argue that a shaman is a hybrid of melee and spell damage, but again, it doesn’t hold water, as a mage does different types of damage, but is clearly a pure class. So, paladin and druid classes are hybrids and I love playing them.
Now, I think an example is the best way to show you why I love playing hybrids. I was playing my fully feral speced druid tank in Botanica on the weekend. The party was a hunter, a druid healer, druid tank, rogue and a warlock. I generally just tanked and held all the mobs on me, while my trusty damage team took out the baddies, and the healer kept us all alive. This is all well and good, but a pure class warrior would have handled this equally well, though with a lot less style then me of course. Where the hybrid really shines is when the shit (yes, we are a pg13 blog and can say shit. No, the FCC can’t charge us a fine.) hits the fan. During our otherwise perfect run, there was one messy pull. You know the one with 5 mobs that polymorph people, spawn additional mobs, and cast that horrible killer AoE on the ground? Yeah, that one. I pulled them to me, and the kill team took out the little beast mobs, but while they were doing that the polymorph mob poly’d the healer, and the killer AoE was thrown. The party’s health was dropping quick and the healer was out of action. I moved my remaining mob back out of the AoE, and stunned him. I popped out of bear form, cast barkskin, popped a fel blossom, and cast tranquility, healing the whole group to full. The mobs were rather pissed about the healing and stayed on me. I popped back to bear as soon as the cast was over, taking very few hits between the fel bubble and barkskin. The healer’s polymorph broke, and he went back to healing and the kill team finished off the polymorpher and then the AoE caster. Now, some of us might have survived, but without that quick hybrid action several players would have gone down.
That is why I love hybrids, we contribute most when it counts. Now I could go on and on, and likely will in other posts, but that really covers the basics for me. Now a poorly skilled or narrow focused player would not be a good hybrid, they lack the imagination and reaction speed to successfully get their hybrid on. That’s right folks! Those who play pure classes have no imagination!
This definition is close, and excludes classes like rogues and mages, which are clearly not hybrid. On the other hand, if you spend too long thinking about it you could claim that most classes in WoW are hybrid. All classes are a mix of damage dealing and some other role. A warrior can be damage dealer and a tank. A priest can be a damage dealer and a healer. This isn’t what I mean by a hybrid class, so how do I define it clearer so it excludes these classes? Well, I think we can safely assume that every class in wow has some flavor of damage dealing available to it through talent trees. So if we exclude this as one of the roles that can be combined to create a hybrid class, we can assume that any class without the ability to heal and tank is not a hybrid class.
This definition limits us to the druid and paladin classes, excluding even shamans which are traditionally thought of as hybrid. People think of shamans as hybrid because they heal and deal damage, but that is no different that a priest, which is most definitely not a hybrid class. I guess you could also argue that a shaman is a hybrid of melee and spell damage, but again, it doesn’t hold water, as a mage does different types of damage, but is clearly a pure class. So, paladin and druid classes are hybrids and I love playing them.
Now, I think an example is the best way to show you why I love playing hybrids. I was playing my fully feral speced druid tank in Botanica on the weekend. The party was a hunter, a druid healer, druid tank, rogue and a warlock. I generally just tanked and held all the mobs on me, while my trusty damage team took out the baddies, and the healer kept us all alive. This is all well and good, but a pure class warrior would have handled this equally well, though with a lot less style then me of course. Where the hybrid really shines is when the shit (yes, we are a pg13 blog and can say shit. No, the FCC can’t charge us a fine.) hits the fan. During our otherwise perfect run, there was one messy pull. You know the one with 5 mobs that polymorph people, spawn additional mobs, and cast that horrible killer AoE on the ground? Yeah, that one. I pulled them to me, and the kill team took out the little beast mobs, but while they were doing that the polymorph mob poly’d the healer, and the killer AoE was thrown. The party’s health was dropping quick and the healer was out of action. I moved my remaining mob back out of the AoE, and stunned him. I popped out of bear form, cast barkskin, popped a fel blossom, and cast tranquility, healing the whole group to full. The mobs were rather pissed about the healing and stayed on me. I popped back to bear as soon as the cast was over, taking very few hits between the fel bubble and barkskin. The healer’s polymorph broke, and he went back to healing and the kill team finished off the polymorpher and then the AoE caster. Now, some of us might have survived, but without that quick hybrid action several players would have gone down.
That is why I love hybrids, we contribute most when it counts. Now I could go on and on, and likely will in other posts, but that really covers the basics for me. Now a poorly skilled or narrow focused player would not be a good hybrid, they lack the imagination and reaction speed to successfully get their hybrid on. That’s right folks! Those who play pure classes have no imagination!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
